Monday, April 13, 2009

Bird's-Eye View

I wanted to excerpt a few lines from the article posted in the previous update to illustrate some broad points about the current debate on democracy and political development in China. I'm no expert, but one thing I have found is that the debate is somewhat richer than I would have guessed before coming here and far richer than most people imagine when they think of the authoritarian Chinese government. This isn't to say or pretend that these conversations take place in a free society, but the discussion even within CCP bounds is fairly interesting.

Anyway, a few quotes from Prof. Yu with my brief comments.

1. "But elections, separation of powers, oversight, participation, consultation and the rule of law can have many forms." (但选举、分权、监督、参与、协商、法治可以有许多形式。)

As Westerners, the above statement leads us to ask whether the author simply needs an out - i.e. some other definition of "democracy" where true liberal democracy is still impossible - or whether our own thinking might indeed be too narrow. I would tend toward the former. Also a benign acknowledgment that democracy varies in the particulars from country to country.

What does an alternative form of rule of law look like? Separation of powers? Elections?

2. "Democratic government is the joint achievement and universal value of mankind's political civilization, and has common essentials." (民主政治是人类政治文明的共同成果和普遍价值,有着共同的要素。)

We (Americans) often are quite willing to talk about the "universal value" part without acknowledging any "joint achievement," or the need for each society to legitimize its government in its own way. But of course according to the CCP China has enjoyed democratic government for decades under a system completely opposed to liberal democracy, and speaking of democracy as in part a Chinese achievement is more natural.

3. "Indirect rule is inseparable from elections. To date, humankind has found no other, better method to replace the electoral style in selecting those officials who can best represent the people's interest and genuinely be responsible for the people." (间接统治就离不开选举。人类到现在还没有找到另外一个更好的办法,来代替选举的形式,把最能代表人民利益并真正对人民负责的官员选出来。)

An interesting admission that I imagine few would guess had been spoken by a CCP official, rural village elections notwithstanding. Still, it gives a primacy to elections that I didn't expect.

4. "At the same time one must soberly see that the proposition of "using party democracy to spur social democracy" itself signifies that party democracy is not the fundamental goal of Chinese democracy, that only democracy of the people is the ultimate objective." (同时必须清醒地看到,“以党内民主带动社会民主”,这一命题本身就意味着,党内民主不是中国民主政治的根本目标,人民民主才是最终目标。)

To my mind this is the most substantive quote in the piece. There has been much talk of expanding "inner-party democracy" to better regulate and police Chinese officialdom. Here Yu goes on to state flat-out that a more popular "social democracy" cannot be put off simply by the achievement of reforms within the government. The means of government must themselves be reformed, eventually, and the final goal is something fundamentally different from what currently exists.

4 comments:

Alb said...

An interesting and nice digest of info. ^_^

I don't really know how to comment on this, because I know so little about the political climate in China. I don't even feel like I have a particularly strong view on things . . .

Nancy W. said...

Glad to see that you're tackling some tough topics, Jackson. Not to mention that it helps me understand some of the concepts you are grappling with. And to point out that the Western definition of democracy is also not precisely a reflection of its Grecian roots. (No pun on Grecian Formula here but only a female would immediately link roots to hair :-) Mom

Unknown said...

Looking forward to you passenger-cabbie interactions when you go back to middle kingdom which are easily as thought provoking, but much more guttural.

Andrew Cockerham said...

I like the final point. It seems to fit with the CCP rhetoric and Chinese thinking that the government is somehow 'evolving' into a better and ultimately democratic government. It fits with the whole 'Communism with Chinese characteristics' idea. Whether its true or not remains to be seen. If its true and eventually they put a democracy in place, wow. But it also seems to be like the perfect thing to say to get people to continue to trust and/or support your government, even if you never plan on really giving up power. Thanks for sharing!